Whats this all about? Why now? Why stay?Well over a month ago I attended a talk by an Openly Gay Priest, Fr. D. Fr. D was awesome. I've never agreed with everything the Catholic Church says about Homosexuality and as it looks now, never will. But I continue to be Catholic. Why? Because it is important that I remain, that and the mystery of the Catholic Faith is what fills my heart with wonder and awe and love. Someday things might change, and they won't change if every queer person or allie leaves the church, because that means that we in a sense perhaps condone what they are doing. Basically leaving doesn't change anything. Fr. D said that the worst thing a gay person can do is leave the church, yet many do. Now i'm not trying to get everyone to come running back to the church because that in my thoughts wouldn't do much good either. Most likely these people have been hurt by the ignorance and fear that the church has bred. The people who have left need to find love and trust again, so maybe tip toe back, decide if Catholosism is right for you, or if its not its not.
I don't like to be preachy, over the last few years i have adapted the saying that is credited with St. Fransis "Preach the gospel at all times and when necessary use words." This is one of those times when words are appropriate.
I've been told.I've been told that I have a difficult cross to bare. Perhaps, but most of the time i don't feel that way. We all have crosses to bare in life, its part of being human. The only time I feel like I have an unbareble cross to carry is when i'm told i do. I've been told to seek counseling, but i don't think i need, at least in the ways that is being insunuated by the "request (as combined with the cross statement). This really only makes me feel worse about myself. I've been told to seek and to live the teachings of Courage. Now i don't mean courage as in strength and power and no fear, rather its an organization that is condoned by the Vatican for "dealing" with homosexuality. In a sense, as i see it, to fulfill a "forced vocation," of Celebit Singlehood. For more information on the teachings of Courage see www.couragerc.org
This is what i feel
Through the teaching of the Catholic Church, there is this idea of brokenness disguised as a compationate approach. In the LGBT community there are some things that i personally don't find morally right for me, however, NOT every LGBT person follows the "mainstream" idea that is portrayed in the movies, TV and what is reported in the news. Normal people, going about their normal day. Its not about some illicit sexual encounters. I don't feel that being LGBT exempts a person from living a Chaste life. A Chaste life is different from a Celebit life, a christian married couple are called to live a Chaste life, and by definition there is no celebicy in a married life (usually, i've heard of some, but according to Catholic doctrine they are not following the vows of a married life. Thats another discussion.)
I for one, don't feel called to live my life as a Celibit Single. will i get married to a man? that is to be seen. will i commit myself to a woman? again that is to be seen. The point is, if i commit myself to a woman according to the church i will be bad, living in sin. In the broad sense of it though i'm not seeking purely sexual relations (now i'm not being unrealistic here, i am a human being). There is more to a commitmet to someone then the sexual pleasure. As an adult I seek an intimate relationship with someone, in the whole meaning of the word. I want to have a person in my life to rejoice with, to cry with, to play with, to eat with, to love with, to hold me up when things are going bad, and i fully expect to be there for this person too. I'm talking beyond a "best friend." A spouse, a partner is more than a best friend, or a parent even. As adults we seek connections with others that go beyond those two relationships. According to Catholic doctrine, as it has been discribed to me and what i've been able to get my hands on, if I end up with a woman than i am making that choice and must resist.
The argument could be had that we must deny ourselves and take up our cross. But i'm not so sure that this is what God had in mind. Every person is called to something by God, whether or not you believe... i believe in God, so hence i believe everyone is called to something (thats a better statement). More then likely, even if you don't believe, in terms of vocation you're following his plan (i feel anyway that this is the case, others may not) only because things happen in your life to have you end up on what ever the particular path your on. So why would someone say "this is God's plan for you and you must follow it or else."
Fr. D sared an antidote about adoption in MA. In MA Gay and Lesbian couples can adopt. The Catholic Church took out all its Adoption agency's out of the state. So you can't have an abortion, but these two loveing, caring women can't give your child a home either. What are your choices? (This is also another discussion.) The Church is so against the idea of LGBT couples having children, that they take away options.
It may be argued: well the chruch set up AIDS hospices and what have you. Well great! Good for them! Go us! But I noticed on the Courage website that AIDS is talked about as a side effect of being a Gay Man. Hm. I don't really have anything more to say on that. Hm sums it up well enough i think.
Courage also tells a LGBT person not to come out. That it forces you into a lable and a community that is unhealthy and detrimental to your spiritual and psychological self. Right, so keeping who you are locked inside yourself and never being able to express yourself is healthy. The stress from that can be detrimental to the point of having actual physical problems. The psychology major in me screams to be heard, that this is a danger to ones psychological self. As for spiritually, God knows you and he can see inside your heart and your mind, He loves, He made you and why would he want you to deny his creation and lock yourself away from Him and others.
For some people the ideas behind Courage are decent, for those called to live a Celebit Single life. However not all are called to it.
In closing
So I remain Catholic. My journey has been and will most likely continue to be difficult, yet whose isn't. My faith is strong, my respect for my religion is sometimes weakened. However, I take comfort in the knowledge that God loves me, He created me exactly how he inteded. Will I have a committed relationship with someone, I don't know, but I like to believe that God will be present in that commitment, because otherwise, whats the point. This is how I see it.
End Note: This posting may be edited multiple times as the thoughts in my mind become clearer. Anyone reading this who wishes to discuss the topic(s) more msg me. Thanks for reading, if you made it all the way through.